These brake discs any good?

Discussion and technical advice for 84-89 AW10 & AW11 MR2. 3A-LU, 4A-GE, 4A-GZE.

Moderators: IMOC Moderators, IMOC Committee Members

Post Reply
dylbie
Posts: 195
Joined: Thu Nov 01, 2007 10:15 am
Location: Bath, UK

These brake discs any good?

Post by dylbie »

I've just changed my front brake pads as I thought they were nackered. (Grinding and wobbling under heavy/prolonged braking) When the pads came off they had loads of life left in them. I have now come to the conclusion that my discs are probably warped.

Does anybody have any idea if these are any good? Or does anyone have them and think they are great/rubbish?

http://cgi.ebay.co.uk/Mk1-MR2-Brake-Dis ... dZViewItem

Cheers guys and girls
:)
IanClements
Posts: 1066
Joined: Wed Sep 21, 2005 1:21 pm
Location: Birmingham

Re: These brake discs any good?

Post by IanClements »

Black Diamond discs are very good for the money and at that price even better.

I had these before upgrading to ST185 brakes but I went cheap on the new discs and you can tell the difference in quality with the smoothness of the braking.

Having said that you do pay extra for them being grooved and drilled and I'm tempted to say it's not really worth it.
Kooga
Posts: 577
Joined: Sun Mar 20, 2005 10:06 pm
Location: Rayleigh, Essex

Re: These brake discs any good?

Post by Kooga »

Copy that...black diamond grooved discs excellent. Got them on the front of mine and hadn't had any of the previous braking issues that i did have (though that said, I put stainless hoses on, DOT 5 fluid and pagid pads at the same time too). Don't really like the pads much as they take too long to warm up and don't give much feel, but the discs are excellent and stop them glazing. Wears pads fast though...
jamiesi

Re: These brake discs any good?

Post by jamiesi »

i was looking at them too :wink:
Tom G
Posts: 342
Joined: Tue Nov 15, 2005 12:48 pm
Location: Bishops Stortford, Herts

Re: These brake discs any good?

Post by Tom G »

I wouldn't recommend them... they came on my 2 and felt pretty normal, and warped after a couple of quick stops! Then I swapped for cheapo discs and EBC red stuff pads - looads better.
So my advice is get some good pads. I've also heard horror stories about drilled discs fracturing.
Icsunonove
Posts: 6149
Joined: Tue Jan 25, 2005 10:37 am
Location: Market Drayton Shropshire
Contact:

Re: These brake discs any good?

Post by Icsunonove »

Tom G wrote: I've also heard horror stories about drilled discs fracturing.


Here's one of my old discs:

Image

Image

:shock:

I'm now running Carbotech XP8 pads on standard plain discs. Works for me! :thumleft:

(EDIT: To be fair these had done a lot of trackdays)
lower
Posts: 438
Joined: Tue Dec 14, 2004 2:05 pm
Location: Leicester

Re: These brake discs any good?

Post by lower »

Different car but i'll see your cracked disc and raise you:
Image
Image

These were Spoon discs, so not cheap. They are not just machine blanks, these have proper curved internal cooling vanes and radiused holes. They did approx 2k road miles and half a rockingham trackday with Ferodo DS2500 pads.

I won't use drilled discs again.
Kooga
Posts: 577
Joined: Sun Mar 20, 2005 10:06 pm
Location: Rayleigh, Essex

Re: These brake discs any good?

Post by Kooga »

Can't look at ebay at work i'm afraid, so assumed they were just grooved like mine. Don't get cross drilled ones-nothing but trouble.. The grooved only ones are the ones I have and are very good though - and all you need on a road car! The grooves are the bit that deglaze the pad and thats really all you're interested in :D
Alan Dell

Re: These brake discs any good?

Post by Alan Dell »

This may be of interest. I have just retired after 50 years as a mechanical engineer, with the last 7 years as design engineer at a disc brake manufacturer. I have also been involved in various forms of motorsport for the same length of time. In 1972 I had the first production gearbox kart with disc brakes from Zip Kart. Great until it rained, then stopping became next to impossible at the first corner. I needed to be in mid grid just to get bounced around the corner!

After much thought, I decided that with the front discs being outside the protection of the wheel on a kart they were likely to be more covered in water in the rain compared to cars. Abvout the same time I saw a photo of a Kawasaki bike being used at Daytona with drilled discs. They must have had the same problem. So I drilled the discs in a similar pattern and lo, problem solved and I could stop for the first corner. The reason was the holes allowed the water that could not be sqeezed off the disc by the pad, to have somewhere to go. This drilling pattern became the norm from then on.

I had no problems with cracking and did not even give it a thought. Later as a design engineer on disc brakes I had, of course, to study many affects of discs, pads and calipers and realised many possible problems.

I would recommend the following. Do not use drilled discs unless it is a special case such as front discs on karts. Use grooves to clear any possible glazing due to the wrong pad/disc/temperature combination. Use discs with a hardness of a minimum of 200HB ie SG iron or steel with a minimum grade of 43. Cast iron is no good.

Alan
Icsunonove
Posts: 6149
Joined: Tue Jan 25, 2005 10:37 am
Location: Market Drayton Shropshire
Contact:

Re: These brake discs any good?

Post by Icsunonove »

Cheers for your very informative reply Alan :thumleft:
mr2mk1chick
Posts: 4079
Joined: Tue May 24, 2005 11:53 am
Location: Leicester

Re: These brake discs any good?

Post by mr2mk1chick »

Tom G wrote:I wouldn't recommend them... they came on my 2 and felt pretty normal, and warped after a couple of quick stops! Then I swapped for cheapo discs and EBC red stuff pads - looads better.
So my advice is get some good pads. I've also heard horror stories about drilled discs fracturing.


I bought then all round for tango - they also warped after spirited road use very quickly (<month) :(

std discs have been perfect for all our mk1s (n/a's and sc) with uprated pads (yellowstuff) for all road and heavy track use. :thumleft:

edit: our track car has grooved 'somethings' on it (can't remember make)

:arrow: also ensure the calipers are serviced to make sure they are not uneven braking, which can itself lead to disc warpage
Image
Grendel
Posts: 1332
Joined: Mon Apr 11, 2005 10:01 am
Location: Southampton

Re: These brake discs any good?

Post by Grendel »

Sorry for another tread hijack but think my pads need changing soon (and hand brake cable) what would people recommend please?
The car is only used as a road car is it worth just going to KwikFit and geting them to replace them with standard pads again?
System-G
Posts: 4554
Joined: Tue Dec 28, 2004 10:50 am
Location: Leicestershire

Re: These brake discs any good?

Post by System-G »

Grendel wrote:Sorry for another tread hijack but think my pads need changing soon (and hand brake cable) what would people recommend please?
The car is only used as a road car is it worth just going to KwikFit and geting them to replace them with standard pads again?


standard discs from Brakes international (or local autofactors) and EBC Redstuff - wouldn't waste time or money on greens or blacks :thumleft:
85 MK1 MR2 Track N/Ail | 99 528i SE Touring | 01 Mandarin VX220
System-G
Posts: 4554
Joined: Tue Dec 28, 2004 10:50 am
Location: Leicestershire

Re: These brake discs any good?

Post by System-G »

mr2mk1chick wrote:

edit: our track car has grooved 'somethings' on it (can't remember make)



Black diamond Grooved (not drilled)... well they were grooved, but the race spec pads have worn the grooves away, but only after about 4000 track miles :thumleft:
85 MK1 MR2 Track N/Ail | 99 528i SE Touring | 01 Mandarin VX220
un1eash
Posts: 4453
Joined: Fri May 13, 2005 8:25 pm
Location: Leicester

Re: These brake discs any good?

Post by un1eash »

Grendel wrote:Sorry for another tread hijack but think my pads need changing soon (and hand brake cable) what would people recommend please?
The car is only used as a road car is it worth just going to KwikFit and geting them to replace them with standard pads again?


EBC greenstuff are perfectly fine for road use and are an improvment over standard pads as i use them.
Tony jinxy froude
Posts: 3533
Joined: Tue Dec 14, 2004 6:27 pm
Location: HERTS

Re: These brake discs any good?

Post by Tony jinxy froude »

Yep i have green stuff pads on the front & rear of my car with black diamond grooved discs all round too, im not overly impressed with the black diamond grooved up front to be honest, they were only replaced last year & within 6 weeks the front were slightly warped, im now considdering getting a different set of grooved discs up front or getting these ones skimmed, anyone any ideas how much skimming should cost ? if its not cost effective i may just go for new grooved discs up front instead :-k , cheers, jinxy
dylbie
Posts: 195
Joined: Thu Nov 01, 2007 10:15 am
Location: Bath, UK

Re: These brake discs any good?

Post by dylbie »

Thanks for the comprehensive information!

A lot of mixed reviews it seems!

I've just spoken to my local performance car garage and the owner is actually a MK1 enthusiast. Its a good place to go if your from around the Bath area.

Anyway he said they're no good, he said they warp really easily and make a hell of a noise. He recommended buying standard discs of a decent manufacturer and keeping the ferrodo race pads that I have.

On another note some little bastards broke in to my Swift GTi last night and stole.... the steering wheel. Seems they have sheared off the spline bit from the top of the column in an effort to break the steering lock! Seems odd though because they left the stereo, which had the head unit and the remote left on it! Now I have to figure out what to do as its stuck on the drive. Anyone have any ideas? I think maybe I'll post in a separate forum
Post Reply

Return to “MR2 MK1 1984-1989 NA & SC”